Stuffed Eggplant with Onion, Tomato and Fresh Herbs

(Last Updated On: August 15, 2017)

I ran across this dish on a month-long visit to Istanbul. Eggplant was in season at the time and we were able to sample quite a few dishes that were new to me. I love traveling to places that aren’t afraid of variety, spice and flavor – Istanbul is one such place. This dish is served room temperature or cold as a light meal or a starter. The name of the dish in Turkish, Imam Bayildi, translates literally to “the Imam fainted”, presumably due to happiness. That gives you an idea of how wonderful it is. The other version of the story is that the Imam fainted after he learned that his new wife used up all of the expensive olive oil they received for their wedding by making this dish several days in a row (his favorite). Some versions of the recipe ask for 1/2 cup of olive oil or more – this is a slimmed down version.


3 – 4 Small Eggplants

1 1/2 Medium White Onions or 2 Small (dice and julienne)

2 Teaspoons Salt

2 Medium Sized Tomatoes (diced)

4 Cloves Garlic (minced)

Juice of 1/2 Lemon

1 Tablespoon Tomato Paste

1 Tablespoon Red Pepper Paste (readily available in Istanbul, but you can substitute with tomato paste)

1/4 Cup Fresh Dill (minced)

1/4 Cup Fresh Mint (minced)

1/4 Cup Fresh Parsley (minced)

1 Teaspoon Honey

1/2 Teaspoon Red Pepper Flakes

2 Teaspoons Sumac

1/4 Cup Olive Oil


Place the onion slices in a bowl with the salt. Roughly squeeze them between your fingers until they become limp.

Add the garlic, sumac, red pepper flakes, honey, fresh herbs, tomatoes and tomato paste to the onions and mix thoroughly.

Prepare the eggplant for stuffing

Method #1: Wash and dry the eggplants. Using a sharp knife, cut off the leaves but leave the white stem core. Place each eggplant on the table to gauge where they will lie flat. On the opposite surface peel off a ribbon of the skin, being careful to allow about 1/2 inch of skin intact on each end. Remove the white part of the flesh under the slice to expose the seeds. Score the inside of the eggplant without piercing the skin. Remove another smaller ribbon of skin on either side of the top peel (optional). Now press the white flesh inside the eggplant with your thumbs, being careful not to puncture the skin. This will create a cavity for stuffing.

Eggplant with cavity for stuffing
Eggplant with cavity ready for stuffing

Method #2: Wash and dry the eggplants. Using a sharp knife, cut off the leaves leaving the white core of the stem. Remove a ribbon of skin on the top being careful to allow about 1/2 inch of skin intact on each side. Brush them with olive oil and then place the eggplant in a 400 degree oven and bake until the skin starts to blacken (about 20 minutes). Allow them to cool and drain (opening side down) for 20 minutes.

Stuff each eggplant with the onion/tomato mixture pressing it in firmly. Place the eggplants side by side in a sauce pan so that they fill the space inside. Heap additional stuffing on top of each one. Drizzle them with the olive oil.

Fill the pan with water until it reaches 1/2 way up the side of the eggplants.

Bring the water to a boil and reduce the heat to simmer. Cover the dish and allow it to cook for 45 minutes, basting with the cooking liquid occasionally. Continue to cook until the onions become translucent (this could be 1 hour or more).

Allow the pan to cool. You can remove the eggplant and serve them each on individual plates when they are room temperature. But if you can wait they will have more flavor if you keep them in the sauce pan overnight and serve them cold the next day.

This dish is also a typical addition to a Turkish Mezze (appetizer) platter.  In Istanbul, when you arrive at a restaurant it isn’t long before the waiter comes along with a tray of mezze samples to order and enjoy with friends. It’s one of my favorite ways to eat. Here are a few addition recipe ideas to create a mezze appetizer platter at home.

Curried Black-Eyed Peas

Yogurt dip with Jalapeno and Fresh Herbs

Turkish Meatballs (Kofte)

Pin the recipe for later:

Stuffed Eggplant

Other related stories about Istanbul that you might enjoy:

Grit, Spice and Delights in Istanbul





Some of the links on this article are affiliate links, which means that if you click on them and make a purchase, we receive a small referral fee. If you find the links useful and do make a purchase, thanks so much for your support!

6 thoughts on “Stuffed Eggplant with Onion, Tomato and Fresh Herbs”

  1. I LOVE to stuff my vegetables and then bake them in the oven. Every week I try to have it once, be it squash, sweet potato, zucchini or eggplant. Interesting how you stuffed it, I usually just cut it in half and spoon out the middle 🙂

Leave a Comment